How to write an appeal letter for a denied insurance claim
Short answer: This guide is about health insurance. Read the denial letter first, because it tells you how and where to appeal. If you want to appeal in writing, state your name, claim number and health insurance ID number, say which decision you are appealing, and ask for a new review. This is general information, not legal advice, and a Cellpostal letter is regular mail, so it is not proof you filed on time.
Write a letter · $5, postage includedFirst, make sure a letter is the right step
A denied claim feels urgent, so slow down for one minute and check these points.
- If your health is at risk right now, call your doctor or 911. Do not wait on mail.
- Read the denial letter. It should say why the claim was denied and how to appeal.
- Look for an appeal form from your insurer. HealthCare.gov says: "Complete all forms required by your health insurer." If the insurer requires a form, fill it out. A letter does not replace it.
- If a lawyer or a patient advocate is helping you, ask before you send anything.
- If you are not sure what to do, you can call 1-800-318-2596, the number HealthCare.gov lists for questions.
What the official page says
HealthCare.gov has a page on internal appeals. It says: "Or you can write to your insurer with your name, claim number, and health insurance ID number." So a written appeal is one way to start, and those three items are the core of your letter.
Cellpostal is not part of, or endorsed by, your insurer or HealthCare.gov. We only print and mail what you type. For a claim that was not denied, see our guide to a letter to an insurance company about a claim. How to write a letter to an insurance company about a claim
Deadlines: do not rely on mail
HealthCare.gov says: "You must file your internal appeal within 180 days (6 months) of receiving notice that your claim was denied." Your denial letter says how long you have, so check it and act on time.
Do not rely on a mailed Cellpostal letter to meet a deadline. Regular mail takes days and has no proof. Cellpostal sends regular First-Class Mail only. It is not certified mail, there is no return receipt and no signature.
Tip. If your deadline is close, ask your insurer how it takes appeals, such as by phone, by an online form or by fax, and use that method yourself.
Use the address on your papers
Your insurer is an institution, so use the appeals address printed on the denial letter or in your plan documents. If you cannot find one, call the number on your insurance card and ask where to send an appeal. Do not guess. Cellpostal sends to US addresses only, a street address or a PO box. Cellpostal cannot mail to APO, FPO or DPO addresses today. Use the street or box address from your papers.
Keep your numbers private
HealthCare.gov says to include your claim number and health insurance ID number. Print the claim number in full, so the insurer can find your file. For your health insurance ID, write only the last 4 digits, such as "ID ending in 4821", and give the full number the way the insurer asks, such as by phone or on its own form.
Tip. Never print your Social Security number or a card number in a Cellpostal letter.
Papers and doctor letters
HealthCare.gov says to "Submit any additional information that you want the insurer to consider, such as a letter from the doctor." It also says: "Keep your original documents and submit copies to your insurance company."
Cellpostal cannot enclose copies, forms, medical records or a doctor letter. Your letter can say, "I can send my medical records if you ask." If you need to include papers right away, mail the full packet yourself and keep copies.
What an appeal letter must say
- Your name and a return address you are fine sharing.
- The word "Appeal" and the date of the denial letter.
- The full claim number and the insurance ID ending in 4 digits.
- What was denied, such as a visit, a test or a prescription.
- One plain reason you think the decision should change.
- A request for a new review and a written answer.
- A line that you can send records if asked.
Write facts, not anger. Say "my doctor ordered this test," not "they are crooks." Keep it to one claim per letter.
Example 1: a visit that was denied
Barret writes about a clinic visit. The letter is plain and makes one ask.
Dear Appeals Department,
My name is Barret. I am appealing the denial of a claim for a clinic visit on [date of service]. The denial letter is dated [date of denial letter]. My claim number is [claim number], and my health insurance ID ends in [last 4 digits].
My doctor sent me to the clinic because of the pain in my knee. The denial letter says the visit was not covered. I do not agree with that decision, and I ask you to review it again.
My doctor ordered the visit after an exam on [date]. I can send my medical records and a letter from my doctor if you ask. Please tell me in writing what you need from me and when you will answer.
I know the denial letter says how long I have to appeal. I am sending this letter by regular mail, so I will also call your office to ask if you have it. If you need a form from me, please tell me which one and where to find it.
The knee pain has made it hard for me to walk to work, and I would like a clear answer so I can plan my care. I am asking only about this one visit. I understand that you may need more time to read my request, and I ask that you write to me when you have made a decision.
Thank you for your time.
Sincerely, Barret
Example 2: a prescription that was denied
Nathaniel writes to ask for a second look at a medicine that was not covered.
Dear Appeals Department,
My name is Nathaniel. I am appealing the denial of coverage for a prescription, described in your letter dated [date of denial letter]. My claim number is [claim number], and my health insurance ID ends in [last 4 digits].
My doctor prescribed this medicine for a health problem I have had for a long time. Your letter says it is not covered. I ask you to look at this decision again. Please tell me in writing what you decide.
I can send my medical records and a note from my doctor if you ask. You can reach me at [phone number].
I have taken this medicine for [length of time], and my doctor says it helps me stay well. If a different medicine is needed in place of this one, please tell me why in your answer, so that I can talk it over with my doctor.
Please also tell me in your letter whether there is a form I must fill out for an appeal, and where I should send it. I am only asking for one review, about this one prescription, and I will answer any questions you have about it. I will keep a copy of this letter for my own files.
Thank you for your help.
Sincerely, Nathaniel
Mailing an appeal from your phone
- Go to cellpostal.com on your phone or computer.
- Choose a letter ($5) or a card ($7). Postage is included.
- Type your message. Sign with your finger. You can use the mic on your phone keyboard to talk, then fix the words it typed.
- Enter the appeals address from your denial letter or plan documents.
- Check your return address. It prints on the envelope, so use one you are fine sharing.
A card holds 8 short lines, about 968 characters, which is too short for most appeals. A letter holds 25 lines, about 3,350 characters. Order at least 10 days before the day you want it there by. This is our suggestion, not a USPS promise. It prints and mails the next business day. Most mail arrives in 4 to 7 days. USPS does not guarantee a delivery date. Cellpostal cannot mail to APO, FPO or DPO addresses today.
Check your appeal before it goes
Does the letter name one claim? Does it say what you ask for? Does it leave out your full ID and Social Security numbers? Did you check the deadline on the denial letter? If yes to all four, send it.
Questions
Does a Cellpostal letter count as proof I filed an appeal?
No. It is regular First-Class Mail with no receipt or tracking, so use a method with proof if your deadline is close.
How long do I have to appeal?
HealthCare.gov says: "You must file your internal appeal within 180 days (6 months) of receiving notice that your claim was denied." Check your denial letter.
Can Cellpostal include my doctor letter?
No. Cellpostal cannot enclose anything, so mail the packet yourself if you must include papers.
Where do I send the appeal?
Use the appeals address on your denial letter or plan documents, or call the number on your insurance card.
How long will the letter take to arrive?
Order at least 10 days before the day you want it there by. This is our suggestion, not a USPS promise. It prints and mails the next business day. Most mail arrives in 4 to 7 days. USPS does not guarantee a delivery date.
Write a letter · $5, postage included